Book Review of What Will People Think?
What Will People Think? by S. J. Hamdan: An Engaging Journey of Identity and Love
As soon as I came across What Will People Think?, I was drawn to the premise of a young woman navigating dual lives, balancing the expectations of her traditional family with her desire to break free through comedy. S. J. Hamdan’s debut novel promised not only wit and humor but also a profound exploration of identity—my curiosity was piqued. I’m so glad I took the plunge because this book is an absolute gem.
At its core, What Will People Think? revolves around Mia, a fact-checker in a busy New York City publication. On the surface, her job seems like a secure choice that earns the approval of her loving Arab grandparents, but by night, Mia fully embraces her other identity: a daring stand-up comedian finding her voice on stage. This dichotomy allows her to express bold truths while wrestling with a deep-seated crush on her boss, Jackson.
Hamdan expertly navigates themes of immigration, racism, and self-discovery, crafting a narrative that is both poignant and engaging. It’s refreshing to read a story that balances serious topics with humor and warmth. While the novel starts at a reflective pace, it gradually accelerates, pulling you deeper into Mia’s world. The rich warmth of her protective grandparents, who serve as a refuge in her tumultuous journey, adds an emotional depth that resonates throughout the book.
One of my favorite aspects was the dual timeline—Hamdan alternates between Mia’s present-day experiences and excerpts from her grandmother’s journal set in 1940s Palestine. This structure not only enriches the narrative but also allows us to witness the essence of familial love and resilience across generations. It’s a masterful technique that underscores how history and heritage shape who we are. These passages often took my breath away, highlighting the stark contrasts between past and present while celebrating the unbreakable bonds of family.
Hamdan’s writing is nothing short of stunning; her ability to shift from the struggles of life in Palestine to the complexities of love and identity in contemporary America is seamless. I found myself both laughing and tearing up in equal measure, captivated by her gift for creating vivid imagery and relatable characters. Notable moments, filled with humor, depth, and soul, resonated deeply with me. The way she brilliantly captures Mia’s internal dilemmas and dreams made her journey feel both personal and universal.
As I closed the book, I was left with a sense of warmth and hope. What Will People Think? is not just a story about balancing dual identities—it’s a touching celebration of staying true to oneself, embracing one’s roots, and understanding the power of family ties. I rated this book 4.5 stars, and it’s clear it will stay with me for a long time.
I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone searching for a heartfelt narrative that seamlessly blends humor with significant themes. If you appreciate stories that delve into the complexities of identity and family, and you enjoy the vibrancy of stand-up comedy woven into your reading experience, then What Will People Think? is for you. This novel profoundly impacted me, urging me to reflect on my own roots and the importance of staying true to who we are—even when we’re navigating the challenging landscapes of our lives. Happy reading!
