Book Review of The Girls in the Stilt House
A Journey Through the Swamp: A Review of The Girls in the Stilt House by Kelly Mustian
From the moment I stumbled upon Kelly Mustian’s debut novel, The Girls in the Stilt House, I felt a magnetic pull towards its profound themes of resilience and sisterhood in a world marred by prejudice. Perhaps it was the evocative setting—the murky swamps of Natchez Trace—or the promise of an unlikely friendship between two young women navigating the turbulent waters of 1923 Mississippi that caught my attention. Whatever it was, I knew I was about to embark on a compelling journey.
At the heart of this poignant tale are Ada Morgan and Matilda “Mattie” Patterson—two girls from vastly different backgrounds yet bound by a shared desperation for survival. Ada, with her disillusioned dreams and troubled past, returns home after a failed romance, only to be thrust into the chaotic fragility of life with her father, Virgil. Conversely, Mattie’s story is steeped in the harsh realities of being a Black sharecropper’s daughter, a life overshadowed by tragedy and unspoken truths. Their convergence is both unexpected and charged, culminating in a bond formed under the weight of an unspeakable secret.
Mustian’s writing is lyrical yet grounded, capturing the very essence of the swamp—its dangers, beauty, and the looming threat of the human condition. The swamp feels like a character in its own right, deepening the mood and illustrating the duality of life: a nurturing yet perilous environment. Several passages left me breathless, particularly when Mustian describes how the swamp holds both shelter and danger, mirroring the tumultuous lives of her characters.
One of the most striking elements of the story is the way it handles themes of race and class. While I initially interpreted the barrier between Ada and Mattie as a mere matter of secrets kept within Mattie’s heart, I found it crucial to recognize the undeniable impact of their racial identities. Mustian cleverly weaves these complexities, using Ada’s curiosity about Mattie’s guarded nature to shed light on the broader societal issues they face. I was particularly taken with Gertie Tuttle, the wise midwife whose nurturing presence provides a counterbalance to the antagonistic forces threatening their safety. Gertie embodies the strength and resilience that women muster when faced with heartache and hardship.
Though some characters may tread into the realm of stereotype, Mustian’s depiction of their villainy serves to heighten the stakes, drawing readers deeper into the girls’ perilous journey. I found myself entwined in their struggles and triumphs, reveling in their moments of courage. The pacing held a nice rhythm, moving from tension to tenderness, often leaving me yearning for more as battles raged both within and outside the titular stilt house.
Ultimately, The Girls in the Stilt House left me with a blend of hope and heartbreak, whispering truths about the power of friendship and the courage it takes to confront one’s demons. I would recommend this gem to anyone who loves stories of personal growth against a backdrop of social upheaval, resonating with the spirit of Where the Crawdads Sing.
This book isn’t just a tale of two girls overcoming adversity; it’s an invitation to ponder the paths we take and the secrets that shape us. I found myself reflecting on my own experiences, recognizing that the bonds we form—even born from the most unlikely circumstances—can carry us through life’s swampy challenges. So grab your copy, settle into a cozy corner, and prepare to be swept away into a world where survival and sisterhood prevail among the shadows.
Discover more about The Girls in the Stilt House on GoodReads >>
