Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice: A Cozy Read with a Sprinkle of Disappointment
As autumn approaches and the air turns crisp, there’s nothing quite like curling up with a book that embodies all the warm, fuzzy feelings of the season. When I stumbled upon Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice by Katie Cicatelli-Kuc, I was immediately captivated by its charming cover and the promise of a modern-day Gilmore Girls vibe wrapped in a sweet YA romance. However, upon delving into the pages, I found myself in a bit of a pumpkin patch quandary.
Set in the picturesque small town of Briar Glen, the story blossoms with all the fall staples—local festivals, baking contests, and pumpkin galore. Lucy, our feisty but a tad bit frustrating protagonist, works in her single mom’s coffee shop, Cup o’ Jo, which is suddenly under threat from the arrival of a corporate chain café right across the street. This is where the plot begins to simmer, especially since the new boy at school, who captures Lucy’s attention, is none other than the son of the new café’s owners.
Despite my initial excitement, I quickly found myself searching for the romance that was supposedly a central theme. To say it was a “YA romance” feels like a stretch when the most intimate moment we, as readers, receive is a hug. The chemistry between Lucy and her crush felt disappointingly muted, overshadowed by the relentless focus on creating the “perfect pumpkin spice latte.” I expected the heart-fluttering moments that a good YA romance tends to deliver, yet here I found myself left wanting.
Character development, too, felt minimal and at times a bit juvenile. Lucy’s cheeky banter often crossed the line into rudeness, which made it challenging to connect with her struggles and desires. I longed for more depth, more exploration of her relationship with her mother, and perhaps a better understanding of what made her tick beyond the confines of the coffee shop or the threat of competition.
Cicatelli-Kuc’s writing style is warm and inviting, embodying the cozy fall aesthetic that drew me in initially. Yet, I felt the pacing faltered, losing momentum in the exploration of deeper connections and character arcs. The story’s focus on superficial elements left it feeling somewhat one-dimensional.
In reflection, I would recommend Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice to those who enjoy light, breezy reads steeped in seasonal charm. While it may not be the standout romance I had hoped for, it could serve as a delightful companion for a cozy fall afternoon, perfect for readers who appreciate more of an atmosphere than intricate character relationships.
As I close this chapter on Lucy’s story, I’m left pondering what might have been. Perhaps there’s magic to be found even in what we didn’t get—an opportunity for all of us alongside a warm cup of pumpkin spice to seek out better narratives in our own lives, just as Lucy embarks on her own journey in the heart of Briar Glen. 🍂
Discover more about Pumpkin Spice & Everything Nice on GoodReads >>