Rediscovering Heartbreak: A Review of If Only I Had Told Her by Laura Nowlin
Hey book lovers! 🤗 Today, I’m finally diving into my thoughts on If Only I Had Told Her by Laura Nowlin, the much-anticipated sequel to If He Had Been With Me. I have to confess, I initially held off on this one since my feelings about the first book were a bit lukewarm. Yet, sometimes curiosity wins, and when I stumbled upon a Barnes & Noble exclusive edition, I thought, “What the heck? Let’s give it a chance.” I’m so glad I did, because this book rekindled some old feelings.
A Familiar Yet New Narrative
For those who are unfamiliar, the sequel revisits familiar ground but through different perspectives, mainly chronicling the aftermath of the emotional turmoil introduced in the first book. The plot kicks off with Finny’s POV, reflecting on events many of us already know from If He Had Been With Me. While I appreciated the deeper dive into Finny’s thoughts, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the first 150 pages felt like a repetition of a heart-wrenching story I’d already experienced. However, I give Nowlin credit for adding layers to the narrative by presenting the viewpoints of Jack and Autumn, too.
My favorite sections were undoubtedly Jack’s. The sense of discovery as we got to know a character we’d only seen from the sidelines was genuinely enriching. Jack’s perspective brought fresh sorrow and poignancy to the narrative—his struggle felt real and gut-wrenching. Autumn, whom I wasn’t too keen on from the first book, surprisingly resonated with me as well. Her pain was articulated so authentically that I found myself deeply empathizing with her thoughts and feelings.
Themes of Love and Loss
The book expertly grapples with themes of grief and unfulfilled potential. One quote that stuck with me—“I know I will always love her in the same way I know I’ll always need oxygen.”—captures exactly the essence of love intertwined with loss. The narrative suggests that love doesn’t simply fade; it lingers, sometimes turning into painful reminders of what could have been.
While I felt the pacing sagged at times, particularly during Finny’s retelling, it eventually built up to an emotional climax that left me feeling raw and exposed. The novel holds a mirror to the universal experience of questioning what we could have done differently, echoing the sentiment of the haunting lines: “If I had known. If I had only known.”
Final Thoughts
In reflecting on my experience, I’d say this book is a bittersweet symphony—an exploration of love that’s just as much about loss as it is about connection. It’s not a light read; it’s heavy with realization and sorrow, but if you’re someone who enjoys delving into the depths of human emotion, this sequel is worth your time.
Overall, I found myself rating this book higher than the first, perhaps due to its reflective nature and the beautifully written perspectives that transformed my understanding of the characters. If you’re a fan of poignant storytelling that offers a new angle on familiar tales—complete with moments that make you tear up—If Only I Had Told Her might just fill the void you didn’t know you had.
So, if you’re up for a reading experience that’ll linger in your heart long after the last page, I encourage you to pick this one up. Happy reading! 📚❤️
Discover more about If Only I Had Told Her (If He Had Been with Me, #2) on GoodReads >>