Book Review: Girls Rule! (Boy/Girl Battle) by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
From the moment I spotted Girls Rule! on the shelf, its playful cover beckoned me—bold colors, cheerful illustrations, and a promise of summer fun. As someone who’s always relished a good tale of rivalry and camaraderie, I couldn’t resist diving into this frenetic world of the Malloys and Hatfords, crafted by the talented Phyllis Reynolds Naylor. Having read several entries in the Boy/Girl Battle series, I was curious to see how the age-old saga of sibling competition and community spirit played out this time.
Set against the backdrop of a fundraising contest for the local hospital, the stakes are high for Caroline Malloy, who dreams of riding on the Strawberry Queen’s float. The rivalry with the Hatford brothers adds a delightful layer of tension. With only two weeks to raise twenty dollars, the race is on, and Naylor captures the intensity of childhood ambition beautifully. The sly undertones of competition are equal parts humorous and relatable, as the kids scramble to outsmart one another using every trick in their entrepreneurial playbook.
What stood out to me was Naylor’s ability to breathe life into her characters. Caroline is endearingly ambitious, embodying the delightful blend of determination and innocence that we typically find in children. The contrasts between the two families are sharply drawn; while the Malloys are spirited and vibrant, the Hatfords bring a charming but more reserved demeanor to the table. Their interactions are rich with charming banter and friendly sabotage—but beneath this lighthearted rivalry lies a deeper commentary on teamwork and resilience.
The writing style is refreshing and accessible, making it an ideal pick for readers aged 8 to 12, and even for adults who want a nostalgic escape. Naylor’s pacing is brisk, which keeps the story engaging and makes it hard to put down. Each chapter unfurls with delightful twists and relatable mishaps that had me chuckling at the characters’ antics. The relatability of their fundraising struggles struck a chord with me; who hasn’t felt the pressure to raise money for a good cause, even when we’re desperate for a taste of something sweet?
One particularly memorable scene involved the various outlandish moneymaking schemes the kids come up with—each successful and each ludicrous—and it not only highlighted their creativity but also showcased the importance of community spirit. Naylor’s deftness in portraying such a battle without losing the essence of childhood bonding was inspiring. A quote that resonated particularly was Caroline’s realization that “winning isn’t everything when you’re surrounded by those you cherish.” It embodies the heart of the story, reinforcing that, while rivalry can be fierce, friendship ultimately triumphs.
Girls Rule! is a delightful read for anyone who enjoys tales of childhood adventures and rivalries. It’s a perfect choice for both young readers looking for an engaging story and adults seeking nostalgic reflections on their own childhood. If you want a book that captures the spirit of summer, fundraising shenanigans, and the ultimate joys of friendship, then look no further. This book transported me back to a simpler time filled with laughter and the sweet taste of strawberries—a reminder that sometimes, it’s not just about winning, but about the memories we make along the way. Happy reading!