Book Review of The Circus Train
Review: The Circus Train by Amita Parikh
When I first stumbled upon The Circus Train by Amita Parikh, I was immediately intrigued. The blend of historical fiction with a circus backdrop promised a unique journey, and having only lightly skimmed the premise, I was drawn in by the allure of a world filled with vibrant colors and complex characters against the dark canvas of World War II. Thanks to Penguin Group Putnam for providing the ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review!
Set against the backdrop of a traveling circus during tumultuous times, the novel introduces us to Lena, a young girl with a disability that prevents her from walking. Joining her on this journey are not only fellow performers but the reality of a war that looms large over them all. Parikh deftly intertwines Lena’s personal struggles with larger themes: family dynamics, identity, and the societal expectations of women during this era. Yet, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the narrative attempted to shoulder too many themes at once, which sometimes made my connection with the story feel distant.
The circus itself is a striking element, and in the beginning, it almost feels like a character in its own right, with its vivid imagery and lively atmosphere. However, as the story unfolds, the intrigue of the circus fades into the background, overshadowed by the weight of war and personal conflict. While the historical element is undoubtedly compelling, I found myself hoping for a greater focus on the circus and its colorful tapestry rather than let it serve as a mere setting for Lena’s growth.
Speaking of Lena, she is a testament to resilience and growth. Her journey, filled with obstacles and moments of heartbreak, shines light on issues like disability and the quest for self-advocacy. I enjoyed witnessing her fight for her rights in a world that often turned a blind eye. However, I also felt the book’s perspective shifts to characters like Alexandre, diluting some of the focus and emotional depth that Lena’s character truly deserves.
When it came to the writing style, Parikh’s prose is lyrical, capturing evocative moments and the stark realities of war. Yet at times, I sensed a pacing issue; the narrative felt drawn out, which affected my overall investment in the climax. The ending, while wrapped in a note of hope, left me craving a resolution that felt more rewarding. I was left feeling a tad disappointed, wanting just a bit more closure, even if it was a happy ending.
For those who treasure historical fiction and are in search of a rich narrative set within the realms of a chaotic world, The Circus Train is a solid choice. It certainly offers a different perspective on World War II, presenting a story that merges the beauty of performance art with a young woman’s quest for agency. Just be prepared for a complex tale that may leave you pondering its many themes long after the last page.
In conclusion, I found The Circus Train to be an emotional ride—one that, despite its length and ambition, delivered a poignant experience that I won’t soon forget. If you’re a lover of historical fiction who seeks stories beyond the battlegrounds, perhaps Lena’s journey through this extraordinary circus will resonate with you as it did with me, in all its heartfelt complexities.
